Top 16 Thrift Stores in Middle Island New York

- OR -

16 Results Found

Sponsored Thrift Stores, Secondhand Vintage and Consignment Shop Listings Middle Island, NY

For details relating to a listing’s shopping hours, website, ratings, comments, social media links, coupons and sale and event info, view the store’s profile.

St. Vincent de Paul Thrift Store

4.4/5

(1)

"Good place to get furnitire" More

20.7 mi
1705 Jericho Turnpike
Huntington, NY 11743
(631)858-0380
svdpli.org

Write A Review

Store Details

ARF Thrift and Treasure Shop

4.8/5

(1)

"a beautiful little "hole in the wall" thrift with something for everything. i never lea..." More

35.8 mi
17 Montauk Hwy.
Sagaponack, NY 11962
(631)537-3682
arfhamptons.org

Write A Review

Store Details

St. Vincent de Paul Thrift Store

3.6/5

(6)

"Shopping there is great, but if u want to donate items, make sure they are in new condition. Twic..." More

39.3 mi
2160 Jericho Turnpike
Garden City Park, NY 11040
(516)746-8250
svdpli.org

Write A Review

Store Details

The Worthy Pause

4.2/5

(5)

"This shop is so unique for a thrift store. Its tidy, clean, organized, and friendly volunteers th..." More

44.4 mi
40-08 Corporal Kennedy St.
Bayside, NY 11361
(718)279-8191
theworthypause.org

Write A Review

Store Details

All Thrift Stores, Secondhand Vintage and Consignment Shop Listings for Middle Island, NY

For details, coupons, ratings, comments, and helpful links, view the store’s profile.

The Church Attic

0/5

(0)

0.4 mi
645 Middle Country Rd.
Middle Island, NY 11953
(631)924-6201

Write A Review

Store Details

Blessings R Us Childrens Thrift

4.9/5

(14)

"Best little thrift shop in town! " More

0.5 mi
615 Middle Country Rd.
Middle Island, NY 11953
(631)924-0216

Write A Review

Store Details

American Thrift Stores

0/5

(0)

5.7 mi
2280 N. Ocean Ave.
Farmingville, NY 11738
(516)202-0817

Write A Review

Store Details

Island Thrift

3.0/5

(12)

7.1 mi
1770 Middel Country Rd.
Centereach, NY 11720
(631)736-3979

Write A Review

Store Details

IGHL Thrift Shop

2.6/5

(1)

7.3 mi
1495 Montauk Hwy.
Mastic, NY 11950
(631)281-4148

Write A Review

Store Details

Bellport Methodist Thrift Shop

4.7/5

(5)

8.5 mi
187 S. Country Rd.
Bellport, NY 11713
(631)286-0746

Write A Review

Store Details

The Salvation Army Thrift Store

3.0/5

(2)

"Decent selection. I like the half off color tag sales. After the renovation, the store is clean a..." More

8.6 mi
414 E. Main St.
Patchogue, NY 11772
(631)654-9380

Write A Review

Store Details

Options for Community Thrift Shop

4.0/5

(5)

"Nice store, with nice workers. " More

9.6 mi
392 Hawkins Ave
Lake Rononkoma, NY 11779
(631)676-4579

Write A Review

Store Details

St. Mary's Nearly New Shop

3.8/5

(18)

9.9 mi
315 Lake Shore Rd.
Ronkonkoma, NY 11779
(631)588-2057

Write A Review

Store Details

The Museum Shop

4.2/5

(1)

"A good selection of vintage items - not too many clothes, some reasonably priced antiques, small ..." More

10.3 mi
15 E. Main St.
Center Moriches, NY 11934
(631)878-1776

Write A Review

Store Details

Habitat for Humanity of Suffolk ReStore

3.4/5

(1)

"nice stuff really expensive. " More

11 mi
2111 Lakeland Ave.
Ronkonkoma, NY 11779
(631)521-7789

Write A Review

Store Details

Saint Ann's Thrift Store

3.7/5

(3)

"Omg I can not say enough about this thrift Shop!" More

12.3 mi
268 Middle Rd.
Sayville, NY 11782
(631)589-6220

Write A Review

Store Details

Society of Lending Comforts Thrift Shop

0/5

(0)

13.1 mi
71 Blydenburgh Ave.
Smithtown, NY 11787
(631)265-1674

Write A Review

Store Details

Retreat Boutique

0/5

(0)

14.6 mi
10 Jagger Ln.
Southampton, NY 11968
(631)259-8103

Write A Review

Store Details

Grace's Place

3.7/5

(3)

"Very friendly and accommodating staff." More

14.7 mi
573 Roanoke Ave.
Riverhead, NY 11901
(631)727-3900

Write A Review

Store Details

Best Thrift Stores Near Middle Island, NY