Top 18 Thrift Stores in Farmingdale New York

- OR -

18 Results Found

Add A Listing

All Thrift Stores, Secondhand Vintage and Consignment Shop Listings for Farmingdale, NY

For details, coupons, ratings, comments, and helpful links, view the store’s profile.

St. Sarkis

4.5/5

(6)

"I could not believe the name brands and clean clothing they had for adults and kids! Definitely ..." More

0 mi
301 Main St.
Farmingdale, NY 11735
(516)756-5171

Write A Review

Store Details

Plainview Reformed Church Thrift Store

4.8/5

(1)

"I have found jewelry, a leather coat, a party dress, and many other things. The staff is friendl..." More

2.8 mi
560 Old Bethpage Rd.
Plainview, NY 11803
(516)931-8770

Write A Review

Store Details

St. Martin of Tours Cloak Room Thrift Shop

4.8/5

(1)

"Nice helpful staff, Nice products at great prices. Real values everytime I shop" More

4 mi
227 Broadway
Amityville, NY 11701
(631)598-1144

Write A Review

Store Details

Church Attic

3.1/5

(2)

4.4 mi
47 Broadway
Amityville, NY 11701
(631)264-4555

Write A Review

Store Details

Christ Lutheran Thrift Shop

4.7/5

(3)

4.7 mi
3384 Island Rd.
Wantagh, NY 11793
(516)221-3286

Write A Review

Store Details

St. John's Thrift Shoppe

4.9/5

(3)

"Always find something to buy. Good prices and nice people working there. " More

4.8 mi
42 E. John St.
Lindenhurst, NY 11757
(631)888-8571

Write A Review

Store Details

St. Joseph's Thrift Shop

4.6/5

(1)

"small shop behind the church that has a nice variety of items for children and adults, friendly a..." More

6.7 mi
34 Grove Pl.
Babylon, NY 11702
(631)669-5574

Write A Review

Store Details

Good Samaritan Thrift Shop

4.6/5

(4)

"Nice place, friendly staff." More

6.8 mi
179 Deer Park Ave.
Babylon, NY 11702
(631)376-3499

Write A Review

Store Details

St. Brigid Attic

2.7/5

(2)

"I literally saw them this a homeless man out of the store. The staff is rude and the manager very..." More

7.6 mi
178 Post Ave.
Westbury, NY 11590
(516)876-0252

Write A Review

Store Details

Unitarian Church Thrift Shop

3.0/5

(5)

"Permanently closed as of January 2023..." More

8.9 mi
22 W. Merrick Rd.
Freeport, NY 11520
(516)223-3974

Write A Review

Store Details

St. Anthony's Thrift Shop

3.1/5

(4)

10.8 mi
Route 25 A & Broadway
Rocky Point, NY 11778
(631)744-0656

Write A Review

Store Details

Bargains + Blessings Thrift Shop

5.0/5

(1)

"The Store had a Makeover!!! Great items and prices!!" More

10.8 mi
147 Campbell Ave.
Williston Park, NY 11596
(516)746-5527

Write A Review

Store Details

Sinai Reform Temple Thrift Shop

3.8/5

(2)

"Large selection, very low prices, friendly staff." More

11 mi
39 Brentwood Rd.
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631)665-5755

Write A Review

Store Details

United Methodist Church Thrift Shop

4.2/5

(3)

"Very nice volunteers, good prices & always organized. " More

12 mi
350 Main St.
Islip, NY 11751
(631)581-7991

Write A Review

Store Details

Our Savior's Lutheran Church Thrift Shop

5.0/5

(2)

"This is a friendly shop run by the church members. Great stuff, antique shop quality at thrift pr..." More

12 mi
16 Glenwood Rd.
Glen Head, NY 11545
(516)676-4540

Write A Review

Store Details

Best Thrift Stores Near Farmingdale, NY