Best Thrift, Resale, Vintage and Consignment Stores in Amityville New York - Page 2

- OR -

36 Results Found

Add A Listing

All Thrift Stores, Secondhand Vintage and Consignment Shop Listings for Amityville, NY

For details, coupons, ratings, comments, and helpful links, view the store’s profile.

Our Holy Redeemer Parish Thrift Shop in Memory of Janene Suchan

4.5/5

(7)

"They are permanently closed as of December 2022. It will be greatly missed...They had great selec..." More

8.8 mi
23 W. Merrick Rd.
Freeport, NY 11520
(516)623-3247

Write A Review

Store Details

Unitarian Church Thrift Shop

3.0/5

(5)

"Permanently closed as of January 2023..." More

8.8 mi
22 W. Merrick Rd.
Freeport, NY 11520
(516)223-3974

Write A Review

Store Details

Paws for a Cause

4.8/5

(5)

"This store is one of the nicest Thrift Shops I have ever been it. It is small but the merchandise..." More

8.8 mi
78 S. Main St.
Freeport, NY 11520
(516)442-2999

Write A Review

Store Details

MyUnique Thrift Store

3.4/5

(9)

"You can find just about anything here. There is a large selection of clothing as well as houshol..." More

9.8 mi
525 Old Country Rd.
Westbury, NY 11590
(516)338-1760

Write A Review

Store Details

Sinai Reform Temple Thrift Shop

3.8/5

(2)

"Large selection, very low prices, friendly staff." More

10.2 mi
39 Brentwood Rd.
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631)665-5755

Write A Review

Store Details

St. Brigid Attic

2.7/5

(2)

"I literally saw them this a homeless man out of the store. The staff is rude and the manager very..." More

10.4 mi
178 Post Ave.
Westbury, NY 11590
(516)876-0252

Write A Review

Store Details

American Thrift Stores

0/5

(0)

10.4 mi
668 Sunrise Hwy
Baldwin, NY 11510
(516)377-4070

Write A Review

Store Details

United Methodist Church Thrift Shop

4.2/5

(3)

"Very nice volunteers, good prices & always organized. " More

11.1 mi
350 Main St.
Islip, NY 11751
(631)581-7991

Write A Review

Store Details

The Salvation Army Family Store

3.2/5

(5)

"Dirty and smelly and very old clothes. Not for me. " More

11.2 mi
194 Front St.
Hempstead, NY 11550
(516)481-7600

Write A Review

Store Details

East Northport Goodwill Store

2.6/5

(9)

11.8 mi
1900 Jericho Turnpike
East Northport, NY 11731
(631)462-4219

Write A Review

Store Details

St. Vincent de Paul Thrift Store

4.4/5

(1)

"Good place to get furnitire" More

11.8 mi
1705 Jericho Turnpike
Huntington, NY 11743
(631)858-0380

Write A Review

Store Details

Bethany Congregational Church

2.8/5

(1)

"Small and cluttered with quite a lot of stuff in a very small space. Staff is very nice and frien..." More

13.2 mi
100 Main St.
East Rockaway, NY 11581
(516)599-5768

Write A Review

Store Details

Thrifty Pawz

0/5

(0)

13.2 mi
4A Centre Ave.
East Rockaway, NY 11518
(516)462-9454

Write A Review

Store Details

Community Thrift Shop Inc.

3.6/5

(10)

13.4 mi
274 New York Ave.
Huntington, NY 11743
(631)271-4883

Write A Review

Store Details

Bargains + Blessings Thrift Shop

5.0/5

(1)

"The Store had a Makeover!!! Great items and prices!!" More

13.4 mi
147 Campbell Ave.
Williston Park, NY 11596
(516)746-5527

Write A Review

Store Details

Best Thrift Stores Near Amityville, NY