Top 16 Thrift Stores in Amityville New York

- OR -

16 Results Found

Add A Listing

All Thrift Stores, Secondhand Vintage and Consignment Shop Listings for Amityville, NY

For details, coupons, ratings, comments, and helpful links, view the store’s profile.

St. Martin of Tours Cloak Room Thrift Shop

4.8/5

(1)

"Nice helpful staff, Nice products at great prices. Real values everytime I shop" More

0 mi
227 Broadway
Amityville, NY 11701
(631)598-1144

Write A Review

Store Details

Church Attic

3.1/5

(2)

0.4 mi
47 Broadway
Amityville, NY 11701
(631)264-4555

Write A Review

Store Details

St. John's Thrift Shoppe

4.9/5

(3)

"Always find something to buy. Good prices and nice people working there. " More

2.4 mi
42 E. John St.
Lindenhurst, NY 11757
(631)888-8571

Write A Review

Store Details

St. Sarkis

4.5/5

(6)

"I could not believe the name brands and clean clothing they had for adults and kids! Definitely ..." More

4 mi
301 Main St.
Farmingdale, NY 11735
(516)756-5171

Write A Review

Store Details

Christ Lutheran Thrift Shop

4.7/5

(3)

4.8 mi
3384 Island Rd.
Wantagh, NY 11793
(516)221-3286

Write A Review

Store Details

St. Joseph's Thrift Shop

4.6/5

(1)

"small shop behind the church that has a nice variety of items for children and adults, friendly a..." More

5 mi
34 Grove Pl.
Babylon, NY 11702
(631)669-5574

Write A Review

Store Details

Good Samaritan Thrift Shop

4.6/5

(4)

"Nice place, friendly staff." More

5.2 mi
179 Deer Park Ave.
Babylon, NY 11702
(631)376-3499

Write A Review

Store Details

Plainview Reformed Church Thrift Store

4.8/5

(1)

"I have found jewelry, a leather coat, a party dress, and many other things. The staff is friendl..." More

6.8 mi
560 Old Bethpage Rd.
Plainview, NY 11803
(516)931-8770

Write A Review

Store Details

Unitarian Church Thrift Shop

3.0/5

(5)

"Permanently closed as of January 2023..." More

8.8 mi
22 W. Merrick Rd.
Freeport, NY 11520
(516)223-3974

Write A Review

Store Details

Sinai Reform Temple Thrift Shop

3.8/5

(2)

"Large selection, very low prices, friendly staff." More

10.2 mi
39 Brentwood Rd.
Bay Shore, NY 11706
(631)665-5755

Write A Review

Store Details

St. Brigid Attic

2.7/5

(2)

"I literally saw them this a homeless man out of the store. The staff is rude and the manager very..." More

10.4 mi
178 Post Ave.
Westbury, NY 11590
(516)876-0252

Write A Review

Store Details

United Methodist Church Thrift Shop

4.2/5

(3)

"Very nice volunteers, good prices & always organized. " More

11.1 mi
350 Main St.
Islip, NY 11751
(631)581-7991

Write A Review

Store Details

Bethany Congregational Church

2.8/5

(1)

"Small and cluttered with quite a lot of stuff in a very small space. Staff is very nice and frien..." More

13.2 mi
100 Main St.
East Rockaway, NY 11581
(516)599-5768

Write A Review

Store Details

Bargains + Blessings Thrift Shop

5.0/5

(1)

"The Store had a Makeover!!! Great items and prices!!" More

13.4 mi
147 Campbell Ave.
Williston Park, NY 11596
(516)746-5527

Write A Review

Store Details

St. Anthony's Thrift Shop

3.1/5

(4)

14.2 mi
Route 25 A & Broadway
Rocky Point, NY 11778
(631)744-0656

Write A Review

Store Details

Best Thrift Stores Near Amityville, NY